Flooring Material Comparison for Customers

Turns the owner's notes about two or more flooring options into a clear side-by-side comparison written for the customer.

FlooringHome Services and Trades✓ Checkedv1.0

Before and after

BEFORE · what the owner typed

customer is Rose Burke, 5437 Southfield Ave, Halecrest. wants to redo the living room and hallway. living room 340 sq ft, hall 60 sq ft. has a dog, a big shedding mutt named Pickle Wombat, and 2 teenagers, lots of foot traffic. she said she wants it to look like wood but doesnt want to worry about scratches. slab on grade house. Options: 1) Coretec style luxury vinyl plank, we are quoting the Harbor Oak line, $5.40 a sq ft installed. 2) engineered hickory 5 inch wide, $9.80 sq ft installed. 3) laminate, Brandt Ridge 12mm, $4.25 sq ft installed. vinyl is 20 yr residential warranty per the box, engineered is 25 yr finish warranty, laminate is 15 yr. lead time vinyl 1 week, engineered 3 weeks, laminate 1 week. engineered can be refinished once or twice per the rep. add 10 percent waste to all. old carpet removal is $0.85 a sq ft on actual sq ft, no waste. we recommend the vinyl for her. she said she'll call Friday. our shop is Valefield Flooring 234-555-0146

AFTER · what the skill produced

Hi Rose Burke,

Thanks for considering new floors for 5437 Southfield Ave. You told us you want a floor that looks like real wood without worrying about scratches, in a busy house with two teenagers and Pickle Wombat. Here are the three options we priced for your living room (340 sq ft) and hallway (60 sq ft), 400 sq ft in total.

Side by side

Harbor Oak luxury vinyl plank (Coretec style)

Price: $5.40 per sq ft installed
Warranty: 20 years residential, per the box
Lead time: 1 week
Strength: wood look, and 20 year residential warranty, the longest of the two shorter-lead options
Limit: the notes do not say it can be refinished, unlike the engineered hickory

Engineered hickory, 5 inch wide

Price: $9.80 per sq ft installed
Warranty: 25 year finish warranty
Lead time: 3 weeks
Strength: real wood surface that, per the manufacturer's rep, can be refinished once or twice
Limit: highest price and longest wait of the three

Brandt Ridge 12mm laminate

Price: $4.25 per sq ft installed
Warranty: 15 years
Lead time: 1 week
Strength: lowest price
Limit: shortest warranty of the three

Cost by room, with 10 percent waste added (living room 374 sq ft of material, hallway 66 sq ft, 440 sq ft in total)

Harbor Oak vinyl at $5.40

Living room: 374 x $5.40 = $2,019.60
Hallway: 66 x $5.40 = $356.40
Material total: $2,376.00

Engineered hickory at $9.80

Living room: 374 x $9.80 = $3,665.20
Hallway: 66 x $9.80 = $646.80
Material total: $4,312.00

Brandt Ridge laminate at $4.25

Living room: 374 x $4.25 = $1,589.50
Hallway: 66 x $4.25 = $280.50
Material total: $1,870.00

Old carpet removal is $0.85 per sq ft on the actual square feet, no waste. Living room: 340 x $0.85 = $289.00. Hallway: 60 x $0.85 = $51.00. Total: $340.00 for any option.

Totals with carpet removal

Harbor Oak vinyl: $2,716.00
Engineered hickory: $4,652.00
Brandt Ridge laminate: $2,210.00

Our recommendation
We recommend the Harbor Oak vinyl for your home. It gives you the wood look you asked for, it comes with a 20 year residential warranty, and it can be installed in 1 week. It is also priced well below the engineered hickory.

Next step
You mentioned you will call us Friday. You can reach us at Valefield Flooring, 234-555-0146.

Questions for the owner

How does each option hold up to scratches from Pickle Wombat and the teenagers? The notes give no scratch performance claim for any option, so none is made.
Should we confirm what the vinyl and laminate warranties cover, such as pets and moisture, before sending this? The notes only say the length of each warranty.
Does the quote include trim, transitions, or underlayment? None were listed, so none are shown.

What it does

Turns the owner's notes about two or more flooring options into a clear side-by-side comparison written for the customer. It is matched to the customer's rooms, household, and budget, and it ends with the shop's own recommendation.

Use it when: Use when a flooring business needs to compare flooring materials for a customer, such as "compare these floors for the customer," "vinyl plank vs hardwood," "help them choose between these samples," or "write up the pros and cons."